I'd give it 4.5 stars, but I don't know how!
We keep going back. There are always lots people there, and I can see why it's so popular. I wish it were a bit quieter inside, but with so many people what else can you expect? (Outside is quieter.) A few years back there was a drop (in my opinion) in the quality of food served, but they have certainly come back — maybe a change of cooking staff. Had one bad experience some time back when no one came to take our order — the bloke who seated us & gave us our menus disappeared, but when we asked someone else she took care of us. My visits in recent years have all been good, and the food is great quality. Nice to have a choice of indoors or outdoors. Their take away pizzas are good, too.