13 reviews about Cagneys

verified email - 08 Sep 2023

Ordered 2 family pizzas but may as well be small as that's how much much topping we got! Only in the centre of the pizza! We're not paying $18-$19 for a family likes back in day, but a healthy $26 - so provide a pizza that matches the price!!! And don't skim on the tomato base. Take some lessons from your city and Lygon street counterparts (who charge the same as you btw!) and ensure their pizzas are moist and not dry.

verified email - 19 Feb 2015

You look at this place from the outside and think it is just a standard take away pizza restaurant, but looks can be deceiving.

We came here for a quick meal while we were in the way home and we will definitely be going back again.

Food was excellent and came out very fast. I was initially concerned when I saw no mention of gluten free in the menu, but quickly realised they were totally on top of it.

Highly recommended to anyone in the area wanting a nice Italian meal.

verified email - 22 Aug 2013

I ordered pizza from here as friends raved about it. I found them to be seriously over priced and really average pizzas - greasy and lacking flavour..
I wouldn't recommend this place - there are heaps of better places around that are far cheaper with shorter wait times too.

verified email - 26 Jul 2013

These guys have been around forever. Used to be our go to, number one pizza shop but have recently dropped off a little. Pizzas started to get a little bit too oily and toppings a little sloppy. That being said, they are still a nice tasting pizza.

verified email - 19 Jun 2013

Great restaurant that I am glad I was introduced to. A group of us visited and had some fantastic meals that were served promptly by courteous staff. The prices were quite reasonable and I would definitely recommend to friends and visit again.

verified email - 19 Jun 2013

These guys have been around for as long as we've lived in the area and rightly so. The pizzas are great and so are their mains. You cant go wrong with Cagneys. They do a particularly good BBQ chicken pizza

Approximate cost: $15

verified email - 30 Jul 2012

Nice pizza. Good base and nice quality toppings. Pasta is nice and has a good selection. Staff always friendly and fast service.

verified email - 15 Jan 2012

Fantastic pizza and choice. Eat in or take away always service with a smile. Not a cheap as others.

verified email - 05 Jan 2012

Hands down the best Pizzas in the area! Excellent selection of traditional and wood fired pizzas... Very quick to make orders and the "american" style french fries are pretty great too!

Approximate cost: $15

verified email - 07 Jun 2011

I love the Ortolano Pizza with Hot salami. I usually do pickups for Pizzas after work. They have not once made us wait. Always on time. Quality of Pizzas beats any Pizza place in the range of their prices.

Approximate cost: $12

Write a review

Business Owners

Want more customers? Join the Happy Customers Program to promote your business with word-of-mouth.

Get a professional looking profile with no advertisements, access tools to attract more customer reviews, receive free marketing materials, use the Live Reviews Widget on your website, plus lots more...

See how it works

Upgrade Your Account